

Michael Gleeson, the ex-boyfriend of a woman at the centre of a bullets-flying feud between former lovers and associates of crime families, pleaded guilty Tuesday afternoon to criminal harassment for a months-long campaign of terror that had Ottawa nightclub owner Monika Taing fearing for her life.
Gleeson, 28, texted Taing thousands of abusive and threatening texts, sent her hundreds of emails, and called her up to 100 times a day from December 2014 to July 2015, court heard.Â
At first, the messages and calls were annoying, but over time became so threatening that Taing, 29, went into hiding and changed her daily routine out of fear for herself and family, court heard. Gleeson would routinely apologize the next day, but even though Taing begged him to leave her alone, he didnât.
In one message, Gleeson threatened that heâd pay some people âto do fâd up (stuff).â
âYou gave me no choice,â he threatened.
Gleeson, who was arrested in July, was sentenced on Tuesday to time served â 231 days at the Ottawa Carleton Detention Centre â and will be on probation for three years. He was also ordered to stay 150 metres away from Taing and provide a DNA sample for the national databank.Â
Taing is a key figure in an Ottawa police anti-gang squad probe into three February shootings believed to be connected to a dispute among herself, Gleeson and associates of the Manasseri crime family and the Alkhalil crime family.
On Feb. 2, police believe, Taing was the intended target of a shooting at a home on Tremblay Road. The nightclub Taing owned was previously seized by national police as part of a financial probe into the dealings of the Alkhalil crime family.
Gleeson ran a Greco Fitness franchise in Little Italy with Kayla and Benny Manasseri Jr. Shots were fired at the gym on Feb. 22. The shooting was considered a message to the owners.
The Manasseris are the children of Benny Manasseri Sr. In 2014, he pleaded guilty to running an illegal sports betting ring connected to organized crime. The court heard during trial that Manasseri was believed to be the head of the ring.
Just six days after the fitness centre shooting, Gleesonâs motherâs home at 319 Selby Ave. was hit with gunfire. Gleesonâs mother was home, sitting and reading at the time. No one was injured. His mother sat in court on Tuesday at the guilty-plea hearing.Â
Itâs not known when the relationship between Taing and Gleeson began.Â
On Tuesday, court heard Gleeson once sent Taing a photograph of himself with a knife to his throat and warned that if she had people coming after him, theyâd better put a bullet in his head, or heâd put one in theirs, court heard. He also said that nobody in her world could âsave herâ and he went on to threaten to âblow peopleâs heads off.â
Taing filed a victim-impact statement with the court in which she described harrowing times.
âI was living a nightmare ⊠No matter how hard I tried to sever all communication and contact from Mr. Gleeson, he always found a way to reach me.â
Taing recounted the endless phone calls and text messages, day and night.
âThe messages were frightening. I feared for everyone. He was willing to hurt anyone I cared about â from the young to the elderly and voiced that no one would be able to stop him. This terrified me,â Taing wrote in her impact statement.
She said he destroyed her pride and reputation and that she felt trapped.
âAll I can hope for is to have my freedom restored and that I may resume a normal life, free of this fear and torment. I continue to fear for my familyâs lives and mine ⊠All I ask is that he leaves us alone. That is all I have ever asked and wanted from him,â she wrote.
With files from Shaamini Yogaretnam
gdimmock@postmedia.com
http://www.twitter.com/crimegarden.com
Â
Â
Thereâs a six-year-old boy in Ottawa who lives in fear the bad man with the mask will return like he said he would.
Itâs been five months since two masked men stormed into his home and terrorized him and a teen boy at gunpoint. The boy still has sleepless nights and parents wonât let their kids play at his house because he keeps talking about âguns and robbers,â and it scares them.Â
Harley Eastman
Harley Eastman, one of the masked men, pleaded guilty to the Oct. 16 home invasion and other crimes Friday at the Elgin Street courthouse. Before sentencing him to four years in a penitentiary, Ontario Court Justice Ann Alder branded him a callous thug who terrorized children in their own home.
The judge said the skeleton masks were scary enough for adults, let alone kids. âPeople deserve to feel safe and be safe,â said Alder, who noted the victims and their families will forever be affected by the home invasion.
The boyâs mother was in tears as she read a moving victim impact statement to a silent courtroom.
She said her son is still too scared to go anywhere in the house alone, and is afraid Eastman will return like he said he would. She said the boyâs fear of masks made Halloween â just days after the home invasion â a nightmare.
âMy trust in people is completely gone,â the mother told court. She said she is riddled with guilt and wrongly blames herself.
âI donât sleep. I sit on my bed and cry almost every single night because of this offence and because I wasnât there to protect them. In a million years, I wouldnât think this could ever happen. It did and there is nothing I can do about it.â
The court also heard a victim impact statement from the teen boy who was also terrorized in the home invasion.
âI find myself scared a lot. I have trouble at night, waking up with night terrors. At night especially, a drop of a pin can set me into a panic ⊠If someone knocks on the door and Iâm home alone, the worst enters my head,â the victim told court.
âI fear this will happen again.â
Eastman, 21, declined to say anything when afforded the opportunity by the judge. The judge said itâs always difficult to send a young man to prison but the nightmarish crime required a federal sentence to send a message to the community that you canât terrorize someone in their own home.
Court heard Eastman was pulling off robberies across town to feed his addiction to fentanyl when he did the home invasion with another man Ottawa police have yet to identify and arrest. The invasion was caught on home security video and shows both men without masks before they donned them and stormed in.
Eastman drew an imitation handgun and pointed it at the six-year-old boy, then forced him into his bedroom and threatened heâd return, court heard.
The young boy tried to barricade himself in his own bedroom out of fear. Eastman then searched the home for anything he could sell to feed his habit. He scooped up $500 US.
This is Eastmanâs first time in prison. He also pleaded guilty Friday to a break and enter, in which he stole a guitar and fenced it to someone who sold it online. Eastman also pleaded guilty to stealing a charity box from a bakery counter in Ottawaâs west end.
gdimmock@postmedia.com
www.twitter.com/crimegarden
In poor health and in a wheelchair, Daniel Rozon, 61, has declared his criminal career is finally over.
From fraud to extortion to knifepoint robbery, Rozon terrorized victims on both sides of the Ottawa River for 40 years.
âBecause I am dying, I want you to know that my criminal career is over,â Rozon told the Citizen as police wheeled him into a waiting Para Transpo vehicle outside the Elgin Street courthouse Monday afternoon.
Rozon served seven years in prison for defrauding a ByWard Market art gallery owner out of $35,000 in 2005. Rozon posed as a military man looking to secretly fund the rebuilding of Iraq with private money. The art dealer fell for the scheme initially but when he refused to hand over a cheque at the last minute, Rozon stole it and ran. The art dealer, embarrassed, never called police.
Rozon, greedy and desperate, returned to the gallery a few weeks later and forced the dealer at gunpoint to go to his bank and give him a certified cheque for another $3,000. In the extortion scheme, Rozon handcuffed the art dealer inside his truck while he cashed the cheque. He then drove him to a cemetery, and threatened to kill the dealer and his wife if he went to police. Rozon made the threat as he stood next to his own brotherâs grave.
Two weeks later, Rozon returned to the gallery and demanded more money at knifepoint, and the dealer cut him a cheque for another $2,000. The art dealer later went to police and Rozon was sentenced to prison for eight years for a series of crimes, including extortion.Â
When Rozon got out of prison, he returned to the owner with a knife and said he needed to be compensated for the time he did behind bars. This time, on Feb. 20, 2013, the art dealer stood his ground and Rozon left with nothing.Â
He then went on a crime spree in West Quebec and was sentenced in January to 10 years in prison.
Rozon was scheduled to go on trial Monday for his latest crime at the art gallery, but instead pleaded guilty to one count of robbery. Represented by defence lawyer Melanie Lord, he was sentenced to only one year for the Ottawa case.
Rozon, suffering from a long list of serious illnesses, is expected to die in prison.
The overcrowded jail on Innes Road has used shower cells to lock up two inmates at the same time or, as the jail calls it, double-bunking.
Only there are no bunks.
Inmates slept on mattresses on the floor, with hopes their bedding wouldnât get wet from the water in the shower room, which has a barred door.Â
The Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services has confirmed there are two shower cells in the jailâs segregation wing. However, how many times they have been used to house inmates is unclear because the ministry has yet to release the numbers. The ministry was also unable to provide numbers on how many times inmate have been double-bunked in either of the two cells, but it did confirm double-bunking has occurred.Â
Brent Ross, the jail authorityâs spokesman, said the shower cells at the Ottawa-Carleton Detention Centre are used as a last resort.
Inmate Larry Seguin will never forget his days in the shower cell back in September. He told Postmedia that when he was shown the bunkless cell, his first order of business was to use towels to mop up the wet floor. It was important to mop up the floor because thatâs where he was forced to sleep.
âIt almost smelled mouldy,â he said.
Seguin, a 44-year-old dad in jail on assault charges, remembers his second day in the shower cell best because he said thatâs when the guard threw down another mattress on the floor next to his. Seguin says he was double-bunked with another inmate for two days.Â
Ross said the ministry was unable to confirm where Seguin was housed.Â
The shower cells are the smallest cells at the jail. They measure eight by 10 feet, including the square footage of the shower stall in the corner, and the seatless stainless steel toilet, the ministry said. Â
Seguinâs lawyer, Paolo Giancaterino, said you wouldnât keep your dog in a place like that.
âOvercrowding at the jail is rampant. There is no dispute. The public should also be aware of what effect overcrowding has on those who are detained in that facility,â Giancaterino said. âWhen a client like Larry Seguin describes being held in a so-called shower cell, it is almost too surreal to believe. To have the ministry allow a human being to be kept in custody in a shower section within the facility is nothing short of disgusting.â
In an Ottawa courtroom last week, Abel Johnson, 30, stood up in a prisonerâs box and said he was sorry for assaulting three Ottawa police officers in January. He pleaded guilty and court heard about his sad life â one he hopes to turn around. But court also heard about his time in the shower cell. His lawyer Jason Gilbert told court that his client spent a week and a half in a shower cell.
In an interview, Gilbert said:Â âAs bad as the conditions have got at the Ottawa jail, never before last month had I heard about anything as preposterous and seemingly unhygienic as a shower room being used as a makeshift, overflow jail cell. For my client or any inmate to be housed in such an environment is beyond unacceptable.â
Ross said that Johnson was never locked up in the shower cell.
Gilbert stands by his client, saying he has no reason to lie about being locked up in the shower cell. He said the information was volunteered by a man who had just come clean in court about assaulting police officers.
As of February, more than one-quarter of the jailâs population was in segregation.
The shower cell was highlighted by NDP critic Jennifer French when she toured the jail after a union leader declared it the worst in Ontario.Â
âEveryone who works in here is doing their best with a half-empty tool kit,â said French, following her visit.Â
http://www.twitter.com/crimegarden
An Ottawa cancer patient in chemotherapy was jailed for four nights on a shoplifting charge after the Crown attorneyâs office would not consent to the release of the petty thief.
Kelly Tennier, 52, who lives at a hospice, missed a checkup while she was in jail.
Her story emerges as problems with the bail system are blamed for overcrowding at the Innes Road jail.
Tennier was arrested for stealing two bottles of vodka on Sunday afternoon. Ottawa police also charged her with breach of probation.
The Crown attorney, after hearing that the accused was in treatment, refused to sign off on her release, so Tennier was shipped in handcuffs to the Ottawa jail.
She had some decisions to make, and fast. She could fight the charges and stay in jail awaiting a bail hearing, running the risk of missing her chemo treatment on Friday. Or, she could plead guilty and hope a judge would free her so she could make her chemo appointment.
She pleaded guilty on Thursday to shoplifting, and the judge sentenced her to time served, allowing her to make her chemo appointment. The judge spared her a 21-day jail sentence the Crown attorneyâs office had originally requested. After hearing defence submissions by Jon Doody, the Crown attorney joined his position for a time-served sentence.
Her options, her lawyer said, were limited. âDoes she really have a choice to fight (the charges)?â defence lawyer Doody asked.
âTo hold someone in jail who is in chemotherapy for petty theft is ridiculous,â Doody said.Â
âI donât see how doing this to someone is in any way in the best interests of the community.â
Doody said someone being sentenced to time served is usually a clear sign the bail system has failed.
âAlmost any time someone receives a sentence for time served, it is an example of the bail system failing, since the judge is not imposing a sentence, the bail system is. We donât know what sentence the judge would have given â including the possibility of no jail time â and it takes away the important sentencing function of the judge,â Doody said.
The lawyer said his client noted that it was pretty overcrowded at the jail but said she had no problems other than missing her checkup.
Doody is among a growing chorus calling for the government to finally put an end to overcrowding at the Ottawa jail with more bail and more space.
âIâve got clients sleeping on the floor,â Doody said.
The Ottawa jail has been under fire after a series of newspaper reports that exposed its conditions â including the fact that inmates, sometimes two at a time, were forced to sleep on the floor of a damp, mouldy shower cell. Yasir Naqvi, the minister responsible for the jail, banned what he called an appalling practice a day after the story was published. He also said he didnât know it was happening.
Days after his edict, it happened again. The jailâs boss, Supt. Maureen Harvey, was subsequently dismissed.
Naqvi has also launched a task force to address the problems at the Ottawa jail, which range from access to health care to overcrowding. It is not yet known who will be appointed to Naqviâs task force.
gdimmock@postmedia.com
www.twitter.com/crimegarden
Tausif Chowdhury, the popular Carleton University student killed on a bike path by the South Keys Transitway station on Nov. 26, 2014, was hammered and stabbed to death in a drug deal gone wrong.
The 23-year-old international student was looking to buy a quarter pound of marijuana and arranged to meet with suppliers who decided to rob him instead. Chowdhury brought a pellet gun that looked like the real thing. Steven Kozielo and John Ruch brought a hammer and a knife to the darkened bike path.
Chowdhury suffered three stab wounds and blunt-force trauma to his face. He managed to walk down the path toward the O Train stop but collapsed and died from severe blood loss from a stab wound to an upper thigh.Â
This week in Ottawa court, Kozielo and Ruch, both 21, pleaded guilty to manslaughter in the 2014 killing. They said they had no intention of killing Chowdhury.Â
In the end, the would-be robbers never stole any of the money Chowdhury brought to buy dope.
Kozielo and Ruch were sentenced to five-and-a-half years in prison. Ruch was granted two years credit for time served so heâll only serve three-and-a-half years.
âIn sentencing my client, the judge clearly considered the fact that he was accepting responsibility for his actions on that evening while also keeping in mind that he is a young man with significant prospects for rehabilitation,â said Paolo Giancaterino, Ruchâs defence lawyer.
Chowdhuryâs body was found by a passing cyclist the next morning, on Nov. 27, 2014 and Ottawa police collected solid evidence from the scene.Â
They found a hammer with the blood of Kozielo and Chowdhury on it, and Ruchâs DNA was found on a cigarette butt near the crime scene.Â
Chowdhury, originally from Bangladesh, came to Ottawa in 2008 to study electrical engineering at Carleton University. His family lives in Saudi Arabia.Â
He was known to police but didnât have a criminal record.
Just after his killing in 2014, friends described him as a brilliant but humble student.Â
The congregation at the Ottawa Mosque performed Chowdhuryâs funeral and his  body was flown to Bangladesh.
Jury selection was underway Monday at the first-degree murder trial of Marc Leduc, accused of killing two women linked to Ottawaâs drugs-for-sex street trade.
Leduc, 59, has pleaded not guilty. His trial for the killings of Pamela Kosmack, 39, and Leanne Lawson, 23, is not expected to hear any evidence until Wednesday.
Potential jurors, one by one, lined up Monday and asked to be excused from duty for various reasons, including problems following evidence in English.Â
Leduc was arrested in February 2013. In an unusual move, Ottawa police held a press conference to announce the first-degree murder charges.
Kosmack, a 39-year-old mother, spent her final moments of life down in the dirt of a darkened bike path on June 4, 2008.
She died a world away from the day her high school principal took her aside and told her she had the smarts to go somewhere in life, somewhere far from her Ritchie Street public-housing project.
Though some news reports in 2008 portrayed Kosmack as a hard-drug addict throwaway, her family has said there was much to celebrate about a great yet troubled life.
At the 2013 press conference following Leducâs arrest, police Chief Charles Bordeleau said investigators had evidence that Kosmack had worked in the sex trade â a claim her family has denied in the past.
Kosmack always made time for her children, saw them every second week and managed to keep her hard-drug habit a secret, her family said.
Leeanne Lawson also lived a hard life and was found dead in a parking lot along King Edward Avenue in September 2011. She had moved to Ottawa as a teen seven years earlier. In 2011 police said she worked in the sex trade to feed a drug addiction. She had been staying at a shelter down the street from where her body was found.
Leducâs arrest came more than a year after former police Chief Vern White held a press conference to warn sex-trade workers about a pattern in unsolved sex-trade killings.Â
The police at the time warned sex-trade workers to work in pairs and in well-lit spots on the street.
In a statement released by the family at the time, they said: âPam wasnât a federal court judge or a grad student. Pam wasnât taken off the street returning home from work one night, but Pam was a loving mother, an adored daughter, a kind, caring and compassionate big sister and a dear friend of many people.â
Jury selection was expected to go into Tuesday and the trial, presided by Ontario Superior Court Justice Hugh McLean, could start hearing evidence Wednesday at the Elgin Street courthouse.
Leduc is being tried on both murder charges at the same time.Â
Â
Hours before he hanged himself in solitary confinement at the Ottawa jail last week, Yousef Hussein, 27, was yelling that he was going to kill himself, according to an inmate who was locked up only a few cells away.
âHe was saying âIâm going to do it. Iâm going to hang myself. I donât want a transfer. Iâm comfortable here,'â said inmate Phoenix Dupras, who is in jail on theft charges and breach of probation.
âHe was yelling loud enough that it woke me up,â Dupras said.
The inmate said Hussein was loudly threatening to kill himself sometime between 10:30 and 11 p.m. last Monday night. He was found dead in his cell by a guard at 3 a.m. in a segregation section of the jail known as âone wing,â where guards are tasked with checking on inmates through the window slots every 20 minutes, and 10 minutes if theyâre on suicide watch.
âItâs pathetic that he wasnât put on a suicide watch (at that time),â Dupras said.
Hussein, who was awaiting trial on sex assault charges, had been on suicide watch but had been recently taken off.
The Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services, which oversees jails in the province, said it will not release any details surrounding the circumstances of Husseinâs detention or his death as several investigations are ongoing.Â
In a recent interview with Postmedia, Husseinâs family said he was sent to solitary confinement for 23 hours a day as punishment for refusing a transfer to another jail to ease overcrowding. His family believes he didnât want to lose the twice-weekly 20-minute visits from relatives or access to the two or three collect phones calls he could make each day while in general population at the Ottawa jail.
Some 71 inmates whose trials are months away were recently transferred from the Innes Road jail so some inmates would no longer have to sleep on the floor, and in some cases, shower cells.
Hussein had spent two years behind bars and was still a year away from his day in court.Â
No nurses were on duty when he hanged himself. Guards performed CPR on Hussein until paramedics arrived. Hussein was taken to hospital and later pronounced dead.Â
âHow could they keep him all this time in jail without any trial?â his brother Ali Hussein recently told Postmedia.
âThey killed him,â Hussein said. âI believe in my heart that they killed him. It doesnât mean they did it by their hands but they did every single thing for him to die inside there.â
Inmate Jacques (Porkchop) Rouschop, who served time alongside Hussein in Dorm 2 (protective custody) said he was a respectful inmate who called his family three times a day. âThatâs what probably drove him crazy. No phone. He couldnât call home.âÂ
Â
Pamela Kosmack may have known her accused killer, but they were anything but friends.
Both Kosmack and Marc Leduc were regulars at the rough-and-tumble Royal Britannia Pub, a since-closed watering hole on Richmond Road.
They were also members of the same chat group, and the jury at Leducâs first-degree murder trial has heard from prosecutors that when another user posted a message asking about Kosmackâs absence on the site, it was Leduc who posted a nasty response saying, âYou donât need to know, sheâs probably out whoring herself.â
In a chilling detail, prosecutors have told the jury that the accused killer was thinking about going to Kosmackâs funeral but no one has testified about it yet.
Kosmack, a 39-year-old mom, was strangled off a bike path near Britannia Park in 2008. Her body was found half-naked and severely beaten about the head, and had bite marks on it.Â
She fought for her life, the jury heard. Leduc is also on trial for the 2011 sex killing of Leeanne Lawson, whose body was found early Sept. 2, 2011 in a parking lot off of King Edward Avenue, not far from the shelter she called home.
She, too, was found half-naked and beaten. Her body, like Kosmackâs, had bite marks on it.
Both women were vulnerable and worked as prostitutes to feed their hard drug habits.
The jury is first hearing details about the Kosmack homicide, and on Friday it heard about her last hours of life and the exhaustive police investigation that followed.
Marc Leduc sketch in the Ottawa courthouse Feb. 7, 2013.
The night before her body was found, Kosmack showed up at a friendâs place. She was on edge and looking for a fix, according to a witness who testified that her boyfriend went on a drug run to hook her up.
That same night, she hit the pub around 10 p.m., according to the bouncer who worked the June 3 shift.
Mohamad Abdallah testified that she tried to bum money off him for a drink and described her as a ânice ladyâ with good humour. He told court he had to ban her from the pub a month earlier for downing drinks from other tables. Abdallah also said he once had to physically subdue and remove a âstrongâ Leduc from the pub. It wasnât explained why he was bounced.
The bouncer couldnât recall ever seeing Kosmack with Leduc at the pub. But the jury has heard that Leduc and Kosmack knew each other because she asked him for toonies so often he nicknamed her âToonie.â
Abdallah also testified that when he was interviewed by police he was not asked about Leduc, a regular at the pub.
Sgt. Pamela Scharf, the lead indent officer, guided the jury through the crime scene, a grassy clearing off a bike path.
Under examination-in-chief by Crown attorney James Cavanagh, the officer detailed graphic photographs and collected evidence, ranging from Kosmackâs bloodstained clothes to a bracelet to a piece of paper with someoneâs phone number on it. The jury has heard that police collected DNA evidence from the scene and that the chances of it matching someone other than Leduc are one in the quadrillions.Â
The identification officer also testified that a review of the scene suggests Kosmack, at some point, may have been dragged.
The jury has been told that Leduc also knew Lawson from the shelter, where he was known for calling sex-trade workers âdirty whores who ruined families.â
The Crown has told the jury that Leduc had both the motive and opportunity to kill.
The trial, presided over by Ontario Superior Court Justice Hugh McLean, continues.
The RCMP officer who chained and shackled his naked 11-year-old son in a darkened Kanata basement only to starve and torture him took the stand in his own defence Monday, saying he feared his boy would grow up to be a sexual predator.
The child, sometimes handcuffed behind his back, lived in the dark for months while the rest of his family went about their daily routine upstairs, seemingly a world away, court has heard.
On Monday, though, the 44-year-old father presented himself as a victim, speaking for hours about his fragile state of mind.
From the witness stand, he detailed the troubles of his own childhood in war-torn Lebanon. He talked about dead bodies, bombs and the day he was raped by a teacher. He spoke of âextreme nightmaresâ from his youth, his troubled career in the RCMP and how a so-called problem child was the last thing he needed.
The boyâs mother was left paralyzed after giving birth and the father had just joined the Mounties. He told the court he was left to tend to his paralyzed girlfriend while taking care of a baby.
He complained about the hardship of fatherhood, saying he had to feed his newborn son every couple of hours and report for work on little sleep. He said his life was upside down and complained: âI had no time to shower.â
âI was a full-time nurse and a full-time RCMP officer, and I had no help,â he testified.
In his own words, he freaked out and said, âI canât handle being a nurse and a police officer.â
So he walked away, but when the boyâs mother died in 2009, he sought and was granted full custody of the child.
But he said his son was different, and so indecent that he reminded him of a bad childhood friend.Â
âWho is this stranger in my house? I was not looking at a little kid. I was dealing with a kid thatâs been there and done that,â the father testified.
The boy, who testified at the trial back in October, said his father wanted him to feel like he was in jail and that the man had punished him to ârid my demons.â
The boy said his father would only come downstairs to feed or beat him. He escaped his suburban dungeon in February 2013, in search of water. Having been fed two peanut butter pitas a day, court has heard, he weighed only 50 pounds when he got loose from his chains. Doctors said he almost starved to death, the court has heard.
His father would videotape disturbing interrogations of his shackled and naked son, forcing him to confess so-called sins, such as kissing a girl up in a tree. The videos, seized from the fatherâs cellphone, were shown in court. âIâve had enough of my punishment ⊠Iâll show you I can change,â the boy pleads in one.
Court heard Monday the father had convinced himself that his son was somehow going to grow up to be a sexual predator, even though a child psychologist concluded otherwise and reported back that the boy was âextremely intelligent.âÂ
The Mountie described himself as a good, sharp investigator and said he had no doubt his son would grow up to become a predator. He testified that even his sonâs hugs seemed vulgar.
The boyâs father and stepmother, both free on bail, are each charged with aggravated assault, forcible confinement and failure to provide necessities of life.
The boyâs father is also charged with sexual assault causing bodily harm, and three counts of assault with a weapon (handcuffs, a wooden stick and a barbecue lighter). The stepmother, a 36-year-old federal government employee, is also charged with assault with a weapon (a wooden spoon).
They are accused of shackling and handcuffing the boy in the basement for six months in 2013. The father is also accused of burning his sonâs genitals with the barbecue lighter.
Court has heard the father admitted to police that he chained and handcuffed his âout-of-controlâ son in the basement because he had run out of options.
He also admitted that he rationed the boyâs meals. The father, who said, âI hate myself for it,â also confessed that he burned his son with the barbecue lighter and once hit him so hard with the back of his hand that the boy was left with a broken tooth, court has heard.
While the boy was not taken for medical attention, his father went to an Ottawa hospital emergency room because he had a small cut on a knuckle from his sonâs tooth, according to his own admission and texts entered into evidence at trial.
He presented himself to Ontario Superior Court Justice Robert Maranger on Monday as a man pushed to the edge, and testified, âI donât know how to deal with this problem.â
The psychologist, hired by the father during a messy custody battle, has told court that he became concerned about the boyâs punishments â including pushups and cold showers â and said that if it happened again heâd call child-protection workers.
âYou canât terrorize your son,â the psychologist recalled telling the Mountie in 2010.
âThe parents saw him as a delinquent. I did not,â the psychologist told court.
The psychologist said he interviewed the boy 14 times and concluded that, after years of chaos, conflict and hostility at home, the boy had given up on any expectation that anyone in the world would love him.
There is a publication ban on the names of the accused to shield the identity of the boy.
The trial continues Tuesday.
A former RCMP counter-terrorism officer who tortured and starved his 11-year-old son in a darkened Kanata basement says he did it because he thought the boy was possessed.
The father took the stand in his own defence for a second day on Tuesday, testifying he was afraid his son would stab him in the heart as he slept. He said he also feared the âout-of-controlâ boy would rape his wife and beat his other children. âI was 100 per cent convinced of this,â he said.
âI was living with the devil at home,â the 44-year-old Mountie, who is now suspended without pay, told the court.
The father intensified disturbing punishments and videotaped interrogations after the boy refused to do his homework, court heard. The police officer had pulled his son out of school in 2012 and homeschooled him.
He presented himself in court again Tuesday as a victim of a âvindictiveâ son, who had âalways rejected me.â He said the child never pitied him for his own troubled childhood in war-torn Lebanon, where the father was raped as a boy. He said his son was a stranger to him, and worse, reminded him of a sexually deviant childhood friend.
âI had an enemy in front of me,â he said. âMe and my son were at war.â
âI didnât care for anybodyâs feelings except my own ⊠the pain he was putting me in ⊠I was in pain and fear the whole time,â said the father, who is mounting a PTSD defence that he didnât know his actions were wrong or have the mental capacity to form the intent needed for a crime.
The courtroom fell silent Tuesday as he admitted to chaining his son to a post in the basement, torturing the shackled and naked child and to rationing his food.
âI hit him. Before the hitting, I burned him (with a barbecue lighter) because I felt the devil lived in him. I needed to defend myself. I was facing something scary,â he said.
The father also admitted that he made his son sleep on the basement floor but denied a series of allegations, ranging from forcing the child to use a slop bucket in the basement as a toilet and forcing him to drink his own urine, and that he tied him up on a Florida trip while the rest of the family hit the beach.Â
The fatherâs testimony corroborates the boyâs earlier testimony that he was shackled in chains, handcuffed in the basement and forced to sleep on the floor until he escaped on Feb. 12, 2013, in search of water. The boy weighed only 50 pounds at that point and doctors said he almost starved to death, court has heard.Â
Under examination-in-chief by defence lawyer Robert Carew, the accused addressed his videotaped interrogations of his son, shown in court. He said it was as though he was looking at someone else. In one video, the naked, shackled boy, his face pale and sunken, is seen begging to be reunited with his family upstairs. âI want my family back!â the boy pleads.
The fatherâs testimony also matched his sonâs words that the man had been trying to ârid my demons.â
âI couldnât believe it ⊠I hated my life,â he said.
The boyâs father and stepmother, both free on bail, are each charged with aggravated assault, forcible confinement, and failure to provide necessities of life.
The boyâs father is also charged with sexual assault causing bodily harm, and three counts of assault with a weapon (handcuffs, wooden stick, and a barbecue lighter). The stepmother, a 36-year-old federal government employee, is also charged with assault with a weapon (a wooden spoon).
The father also testified that his wife, the boyâs stepmom, never witnessed any of the abuse.
The father in this case won full custody of the boy after his biological mom died in 2009. A child psychologist has testified that although the boyâs parents reported their son was a delinquent, he found nothing of the sort, and reported that he was an extremely intelligent kid, despite his fatherâs âterrorizing.âÂ
Â
Â
The Mountie on trial for torturing and starving his 11-year-old son enlisted his brother â a priest â to perform an exorcism on the âpossessedâ boy.
âI thought the devilâs inside him. I saw his eyes and heard his voice,â the Mountie told court Wednesday.
His chilling testimony came during questioning by lawyer Anne London Weinstein, who is defending the Mountieâs wife, also on trial for confining the boy and failing to give him lifeâs basic needs. His wife, who still wears her wedding ring, is not testifying.
Itâs not clear when or where the exorcism was performed, but it was sometime before September 2012, and before the Mountie started chaining up his son in their Kanata basement.
The Mountie, suspended without pay, has also admitted to burning his shackled, naked son with a barbecue lighter as a punishment for so-called impure thoughts.
It was the Mountieâs third day on the stand and when asked about the exorcism, he said his son reminded him of the girl in the 1973 horror film The Exorcist.
Itâs not clear where they prayed to rid the boyâs âdemonsâ but the child, now 14, told investigators he thinks it was in his home because he recalls his father and the priest using a crucifix from the kitchen wall to perform the Rite of Exorcism.
The Mountie, who has presented himself as a victim during his testimony, said he had run out of options with his âout-of-controlâ son.
He also rationed his food to the point that the boy weighed only 50 pounds on the day â Feb. 12, 2013 â he escaped his chains in search of water while his family was out shopping. Doctors, some of whom cried at the sight of his emaciated, tiny frame, said he almost starved to death.
Under cross-examination by Crown Attorney Michael Boyce, the Mountie appeared rattled when asked about burning his sonâs genitals as a âhorrificâ punishment.
âI was in a deep fog. I didnât appreciate what I was doing to my son,â the 44-year-old father said.
The accused is mounting a PTSD defence with the hope he can show he didnât have the mental capacity needed to form intent.
âI didnât know it was morally wrong,â he testified.
The Mountie said a doctor told him he had PTSD after his February 2013 arrest, and said he had never heard of the condition before his diagnosis.
His condition, he said, grew from his own troubled childhood in war-torn Lebanon. He has spoken of dead bodies, bombs and being raped as a boy.
The prosecutor firmly established that the accused was able to ace his RCMP exams and didnât report any flashbacks until after his arrest for terrorizing his son.
The priest enlisted for the boyâs exorcism testified last year and defended his brother, the Mountie.
But he told court he had memory problems due to his âprofessional habit,â and that he had trained his brain to flush away facts after so many years of hearing confession.
Marie Dufort, the prosecutor who questioned him at the time, established the boy had never exhibited any out-of-control behaviour in the priestâs presence.
The reality, the prosecutor said, was that the abused boyâs father exaggerated his sonâs behaviour to justify the torture and that all of the boyâs so-called problems the priest knew about were detailed exclusively by the boyâs father.
The father and stepmother, both free on bail, are each charged with aggravated assault, forcible confinement, and failure to provide necessities of life.
His father is also charged with sexual assault causing bodily harm, and three counts of assault with a weapon. The stepmother, a 36-year-old federal government employee, is also charged with assault with a weapon.
The Mountie testified Wednesday that his wife, the boyâs stepmom, didnât witness any of the abuse. In a February 2013 interview with police, the stepmom said she felt guilty for not protecting the boy.
There is a publication ban on the names of the accused and the priest to shield the identity of the boy.
gdimmock@postmedia.com
www.twitter.com/crimegarden
The defining images of Ottawaâs child-torture case â the most horrific police officers say theyâve seen â were revisited Friday, showing the interrogation a former RCMP counter-terrorism investigator put his frightened, naked and shackled 11-year-old son through in their Kanata basement.
The series of haunting videos â 45 minutes, and 12 seconds in all â were seized from the 44-year-old fatherâs phone on the day of his arrest, hours after his emaciated son escaped his suburban dungeon in search of water on Feb. 12, 2013. He had been shackled in the basement next to a slop bucket as the rest of his family went about daily life upstairs.
The videotaped interrogations were first shown in court last year, reducing police detectives and lawyers to tears. It was one of those times when a courtroom really did fall silent.
The boyâs relatives were beside themselves. The boyâs father kept his head down for most of it, but rubbed his eyes after the few times he looked up at the screen. The father admitted this week that he confined his son in the basement, starved him and burned his genitals because he thought he was the devil.
The videos were played again at his parentsâ child-torture trial Friday, during the cross-examination of the Mountie.
The naked, emaciated boy is seen sobbing as he promises his father heâll stop lying. The starving boy looks frightened beyond description.
He says heâll be a good boy and stop picking the padlock on his shackles.
âI want my family back,â the boy begs in the Jan. 3, 2013 video.
âIâve had enough of my punishment. Iâll stop lying ⊠Iâll show you I can change. Iâm going to keep my locks as tight as possible on my feet.â
The father is heard demanding the boy to confess to his âsins,â including the time he kissed a girlâs hand as they sat up in a tree.
âYou havenât repented yet! You will weep blood for what you have done. I donât see you on your knees yet,â the father tells his son, who was handcuffed behind his back and chained up in the unfinished basement.
âIf youâre in this position, itâs because someone has had enough of you,â the father says during the interrogation in English and French. âYou will pray that Jesus will take you back after all of this and that your parents will take you back.â
In one of the videos, the father threatens to distribute the video âto the people you most care for.â
The boyâs father and stepmother, both free on bail, are each charged with aggravated assault, forcible confinement, and failure to provide necessities of life. They are prohibited from communicating while on bail. They still wear their wedding rings.
The Mountie, now suspended, testified this week that when he watched the videos, it was like he was looking at someone else. Someone, anyone, other than himself, he said. Heâs mounting a not criminally responsible defence, saying he suffers from PTSD and couldnât have formed the mental capacity to form intent, let alone have known it was wrong.
The boy, who testified last year, said heâd been trying to escape for a month. He weighed only 50 pounds on the day he escaped.
The boy still expressed loyalty to his father after escaping his chains.
âMy dad didnât do anything wrong. I donât want him to go to jail,â the boy told authorities, according to notes previously read into the court record.
The boy also felt like he was the one who did something wrong. âMy dad is in the RCMP. He would know.â
The boy was assured that he did nothing wrong.It wasnât the first time Ottawa police got a call about the child. Two years earlier, the boy had gone to a neighbourâs saying he was hungry and wanted to stay the night because he was being punished at home. Police were called and returned him to his home, court heard.
The father has said he chained and handcuffed his âout-of-controlâ son in the basement because he had run out of options. He also admitted that he rationed the boyâs meals down to just two peanut-butter pitas a day. The father, who told police âI hate myself for itâ, also confessed that he burned his son with a BBQ lighter and once hit him so hard with the back of his hand that the boy was left with a broken tooth.
The trial, presided by Ontario Superior Court Justice Robert Maranger, continues.
Another Ontario jail boss has been dismissed amid a spotlight on conditions at provincial jails.
Karen Barclay, the superintendent of the Brockville Jail and St. Lawrence Valley Correctional Centre has been dismissed weeks after Ottawa jail boss Maureen Harvey was let go following a series of newspaper reports about the Innes Road jail, including the fact that inmates, sometimes two at a time, were forced to sleep on the floor of a damp, mouldy shower cell.
Yasir Naqvi, the minister responsible for the jail, banned what he called an appalling practice a day after the Citizen story was published last month. The Ottawa politician said he didnât know it was happening.
Days after his edict, it happened again and the jailâs boss, Supt. Harvey, was dismissed.
Her counterpart at the Brockville jail was let go Thursday, and the ministry wonât say why.
Asked about her status Friday, a government spokesman Andrew Morrison said:Â âThe superintendent at the Brockville jail is no longer employed by the ministry. It would be inappropriate to provide any further details as this is an internal human resources matter.â
Yasir Naqvi, the cabinet minister in charge of jails, has launched a task force to address the problems at the Ottawa-Carleton Detention Centre, which range from access to health care to overcrowding.
Barclay worked in the federal prison system for almost 20 years before being hired as the Brockville jail boss.
âI love working in the correctional institutions with the day-to-day reality you face,â Barclay told The Recorder and Times in 2011 when she was hired.
âIâve been looking for years to get to Brockville. Being chosen (as superintendent here) allows me to maintain my passion for corrections and be with my family at the same time,â she said.
She said she was trying to make a âpositive impact at the institutional level.â
Her counterpart at the Ottawa jail was dismissed last month about two hours after a memo was issued directing staff to stop putting inmates into shower cells.
The memo was distributed after this paper inquired about staff reports that shower cells were still being used, even though Naqvi had ordered an end to what he called a âcompletely unacceptableâ and âappallingâ practice.
Senator Patrick Brazeau has broken his silence about his darkest hour â the night he slit his throat with a cleaver and started bleeding to death on the kitchen floor.
It was Jan. 18 and Brazeau had done his best to drink away his mess. But 12 Molson Export and a bottle of Scotch were no match for the tornado in his mind. Prosecutors had dropped a sex assault charge against him but his trials for fraud and impaired charges loomed. The suspended senator had never felt so alone, so broke. He had forgotten the pride and confidence that had propelled him to become a national aboriginal leader and later the countryâs youngest senator. He could think only of the towering fall that had played out on the nightly news.
His world had collapsed around him. Hope had faded and he thought he had no good reason to live.
âEverything just came to a tipping point. ⊠Iâm not proud of that moment, because I let a lot of people down,â Brazeau, 41, recalled.
âIâm just glad to be alive ⊠and Iâm a damn lucky guy I still have my family with me,â he said.
In interviews during a canoe-camping trip to an island 60 kilometres north of Ottawa in the Gatineau River, Brazeau shared intimate details about the night he tried to kill himself, and spoke of hope â now that he has it â for his future.
The island is north of the Paugan Dam near Low, Que. Beavers swim in pairs, the common loons dive in the morning-still water and a woodpeckerâs rat-a-tat-tat on a white pine sprinkles sawdust from the sky. It is a place the senator calls âpeaceful,â particularly when the sun dances on the river as the easterly wind picks up. It is a traditional corridor for Brazeauâs people, the Algonquin. This is where they hunted and fished long before the river was dammed in 1928.
In his own words, Brazeau didnât know the depth of his rock-bottom.
He found out, shortly before 10 p.m. on Jan. 18.
First, he slashed his left arm repeatedly, then texted a picture of the real-time gore to his girlfriend. Then he texted her that he was going to kill himself. If that was a call for help, his next act was anything but. He locked the door, and as a music mix ranging from AC/DC to Kid Rock played on, he laid down on the kitchen floor and, with a cleaver in his right hand, slit his throat from under his left earlobe across to the right side of his Adamâs apple.Â
âI remember the blood just starting to gush,â he said.
Then he remembers his dog, a Lhasa Apso named Ti-PÚre, licking his forehead.
His girlfriend had called a neighbour when she got his chilling text. That neighbour raced over only to see Brazeau (through a window) on the floor in a pool of blood. The neighbour called 911, and paramedics broke down the locked door. Brazeau started struggling with the paramedics. He wrongly thought he was going to be handcuffed and sent back to jail, one of his biggest fears.Â
He lost consciousness and, after 30 hours in a medically induced coma, woke up alone in a room at the Hull hospital. At first, he thought he was having a really bad dream.
He also felt regret of the worst kind.
âI had regrets that I had failed in my attempt to kill myself,â he says. Heâs ashamed he had that regret, but thatâs how he felt at the time.
Months later, not a day goes by without him saying heâs glad to be alive.
Patrick Brazeau went on a canoe-camping trip, and told the Citizen how the events of recent months have changed him.
Â
BORN ON Nov. 11, 1974, Patrick Richard Brazeau was raised in working-class Maniwaki, Que., some 130 km north of Ottawa. His neighbourhood is a patchwork of residential homes and commercial buildings. His family home sits on a corner, where his father Marcel (now in his late 70s) once ran Depanneur Brazeau and later his mother, Huguette, a daycare. So everyone knows his family.Â
His father is Algonquin, and his mother, who died 12 years ago, was white. He was raised with a foot in two different cultures, but it was hard for him to fit in with either. In his own words, he was too white for the on-reserve folks, and too Indian for off-reserve folks.Â
Still, he had a better childhood than many. Two parents with jobs and a corner store full of food.
His inability to truly fit in with either culture fortified a defence-mechanism within Brazeau, who says he had to walk around as a tough guy, one to never show his soft interior. The reality is that heâs an emotional man who spent years building his confidence.
He developed a tough shell to counter taunts as a boy. His father was strict and enforced school as a priority. Brazeau only went to the dentist on PD days so there was no missing school. His mother always rolled out the comfort mat, notably when a young Brazeau was having problems, mostly with girlfriends. She could calm him down with few words.
As a young, rising political star in the Congress of Aboriginal Peoples, he used his life experiences to try to relate to both off- and on-reserve aboriginals, and later in the Harper government, to which he remained loyal until he was expelled.Â
The Senate appointment in 2008 took Brazeau by surprise, he says, especially after he had brushed off the Tories when they asked him to parachute into Quebec as a candidate in that yearâs election. He said, at the time, he never thought he was Harperâs âtoken Indianâ but now he believes otherwise.Â
Less than five years later, he was ousted from caucus and voted out of the Senate after his sex assault and fraud charges.
His sexual assault trial heard ugly testimony. A woman told court he had pushed her down a flight of stairs, hit her head against a wall, pulled her pants down and tried to penetrate her with his finger. Eventually, the charge was dismissed due to lack of evidence. He did plead guilty to simple assault and cocaine possession, but was granted an absolute discharge, sparing him a criminal record.
The outstanding fraud and breach of trust charges are related to disputed Senate housing expense claims for his primary residence in Maniwaki.
Brazeau said heâs hopeful that heâll beat the fraud charges if the case goes to trial next year.
Patrick Brazeau says going back to jail was one of his biggest fears.
Â
IT WAS one of those sharp conversations a father shouldnât have to have with their son.
Marcel Brazeau lost his father at 15, left the reserve days later, and went on to become a successful businessman. He helped raise three sons and, on Jan. 25, he sat across from his youngest and delivered words Patrick Brazeau will never forget.Â
It was time, his father advised, to stop playing the victim. It was time for him to âget up and fight for my life,â Patrick recalled. âIf I followed in his footsteps, everything would be OK.â
His father hadnât had it easy, but he never folded the hand he was dealt.
Patrick Brazeau became a political high roller early in life. At 27, the U of O law student took a summer job at the Congress of Aboriginal Peoples. He was later elected national chief at 32. Two years later, in 2008, he was appointed to the Senate of Canada and showed up for work in a Porsche.Â
In his own words, his political ascent was built on these foundation blocks â consensus, knowing the file, charisma and good looks (heâs a former model).Â
But the foundation of his personal life was less solid.Â
Heâs never liked being alone. Itâs why he had such a hard time in a jail cell after his arrests. Itâs also the reason heâs had more girlfriends than most. His father has pictures in the living room of all nine of his grandchildren. Five of them are Patrickâs.Â
To say his last three years have been âpretty difficultâ is an understatement. Heâs been in more mud than most politicians are in their entire careers.
But heâs taken his fatherâs advice to heart, and is now fighting âto save myself.â Heâs in therapy five times a month and has completed five months in rehab, where he said he didnât disclose any intimate details about his troubled life. Still, he learned a lot â not from the counsellors, but rather from the other patients.
âItâs time to get back to the basics and start appreciating life,â a humbled Brazeau said.Â
Unlike most, his problems were intensified because they made the news. âI remember waking up, opening the blinds and seeing the media parked outside. It was tough. It was like an 18-wheeler coming at you.â
Patrick Brazeau says a difficult, honest talk with his father has put him on a new path.
Â
The senator hopes the story of his suicide attempt will help young aboriginals.
His message is simple: I tried it. Donât do it.
âThereâs hope. Thereâs another day,â Brazeau preached.
He had lost hope on Jan. 18. âI couldnât cope anymore.âÂ
He now tells everyone he meets that heâs lucky to have lived another day. He spent Motherâs Day with his infant daughter. He seemed happy again. But his life is a âwork in progress.â
He hasnât seen a paycheque in a year because the Senate has reclaimed what it considers questionable housing expenses filed by Brazeau, who has yet to be tried on the charges.
He said he can now count his close friends on one hand, and three of them are family.
His mind is getting straight again, and his ambition has returned. One of his goals is to sit in the Senate again and âreally make a difference.â
But, he says: âIâm still not out of the woods yet.â
The accused killers â secret lovers who worked the same shifts as OC Transpo drivers â sat quietly, a few feet apart in the prisonerâs box Thursday as their first-degree murder trial heard testimony from a clairvoyant they hired.
Susanne Shields, a civil servant and part-time clairvoyant who says she can speak to the dead, recalled for the court the hateful nicknames that Bhupinderpal Gill and his mistress, Gurpreet Ronald, used to describe Jagtar Gill, who was slain in her Barrhaven home on her wedding anniversary in January 2014 as she was recovering from surgery in the family room. Her throat was slashed and her head bludgeoned.
Ronald called the victim âThe Devilâ and Gill called his wife âNazi woman,â the witness testified. âRonald said she was just a horrible, evil woman,â Shields said.
During a 2012 session to discuss the future, Ronald said âwe will do anything to be together,â the clairvoyant recalled.
Gill, a man of few words, just nodded Yes, she recounted.
Bhupinderpal Gill is charged with first-degree murder in the killing of his wife, Jagtar Gill.
Gurpreet Ronald is his co-accused.
It was crystal clear, according to the clairvoyant, that the secret lovers despised Jagtar Gill.
âShe was the Nazi woman. The kids would often call her that ⊠the dictator. She made the rules,â she testified.
She advised Gill not to talk about anyone like that, let alone his wife.
In sometimes tearful testimony, the clairvoyant revealed intimate details about the marriages of the accused killers: Ronald thought her husband was a lousy bread winner and she wanted an out. And Gill, who often called his wife âHitler woman,â said divorce was not an option for fear heâd lose his children.
Shields, who keeps a downtown office for her part-time business as a clairvoyant â she mentioned the address while on the stand â also has a third line of âamateurâ work flipping houses, telling court that sheâs moved 11 of them.
The accused killers didnât just hire her for her psychic powers. Both the Gills and Ronald were selling their homes and they hired the clairvoyant to stage them using feng shui.
The clairvoyant told court that she didnât invent the ancient Chinese system of harmony, and noted that both Disneyland and Donald Trump use it. The Gillsâ home sold three weeks after the clairvoyant did an eight-hour consultation at their home.
When asked about Jagtar Gill, she dabbed at tears and described her as forever generous, saying she cooked her meals to bring home, on top of the $2,000 bill for staging the Barrhaven home.
She also testified that Jagtar Gill suspected her husband was cheating on her, and recounted the time Jagtar followed the secret lovers on their way to OC Transpo early one morning and, at a stop, asked out of her car window if they were having an affair.
Earlier Thursday, Ronaldâs defence lawyer, Michael Smith, questioned the policeâs handling of the crime scene, establishing that some 19 people were in and out of it, walking around, with someone leaving a foot impression on a key piece of evidence, and another walking close to the deceased, accidentally kicking over a cup on the floor.
The police got around to the process of eliminating footwear impressions one year later, and compared the impressions of eight police officers, but didnât do so for all the other people in the house â from paramedics, to Gill, his daughter, one of her friends, two victim-crisis workers and the coroner.
The footwear impression on the tip of a bloody latex glove â the ring finger â was not good enough to compare to others with 100 per cent certainty, Ottawa police Const. Julie Dobler testified.
The police theory, adopted by the Crown, is that the secret lovers conspired to kill Jagtar Gill. Her husband and mistress have pleaded not guilty and Bhupinderpal Gill is expected to testify in his own defence.
The trial before Ontario Superior Court Justice Julianne Parfett continues Friday.
gdimmock@postmedia.com
www.twitter.com/crimegarden
It wasnât just any nod.
This was a nod â up and down for Yes â from OC Transpo driver Bhupinderpal Gill, and he was agreeing with his mistress when she told a psychic that the secret lovers would do anything to be together. Gill, a man of few words, didnât say anything, but he gave that nod.
At least thatâs how psychic Susanne Shields recalled it in court Friday at murder trial of Gill and his mistress, fellow city bus driver Gurpreet Ronald. The pair are on trial for the Jan. 29, 2014 slaying of Gillâs wife, 43-year-old Jagtar Gill. She was slashed and bludgeoned to death in the family room of her Barrhaven home.
But it seemed as though the psychic was the one on trial in a packed Ottawa courtroom Friday.
Under a detailed cross-examination by defence lawyer James Harbic, the psychic defended herself against a blistering allegation.
âYou made it up!â Harbic charged.
âThat is absolutely not true,â the psychic shot back. âI have no benefit to lie.â
The defence lawyer accused her of fabricating evidence to exact revenge on Gill after a falling out.Â
âThereâs no getting back at anyone,â the psychic replied.
Harbic firmly established that it was the first time anyone had ever heard about the incriminating nod.
Shields didnât mention it in her 2014 interview with police or at the preliminary hearing in 2015, court heard.
But the psychic had an answer, saying it was the first time she mentioned the nod because nobody had ever asked her about it.
The clairvoyant, who was hired by the accused killers in 2012, told court that they had awful nicknames for the victim, ranging from âThe Devilâ to âNazi woman.â
The psychic testified she hears and sees âloved ones from the other side.â She testified she contacted police after the killing not because she recognized the Gill name in the news, but rather because a âvoiceâ had told her about the murder.
The cross-examination of the psychic was designed to hammer away at the credibility of the Crown witness, who told court she had such trouble with dates and numbers that she doesnât know her own age.
The clairvoyant has so far dropped her business street address eight times while on the stand.
She was hired as a clairvoyant by the lovers in 2012, and later staged their homes using feng shui.Â
She testified Friday that she purchased crystals and wind chimes for the Gill home to help flow the energy. She charged them $2,400 for the job.Â
Gill was upset the house didnât fetch his asking price and blamed the clairvoyant. She told court that he called her awful names that left her âmortified.â She also said she did everything she could to get the house the best price.
The clairvoyant testified that the accused killers hated the victim and that both were unhappy in their marriages. (The Gill marriage was arranged).
Questioned about her powers, the clairvoyant told court that a psychiatrist concluded that sheâs âas normal as normal can be in a world thatâs not normal.â
The psychic testified that her powers as a medium for the dead have often been verified by raising intimate details about the lives of the living and the dead.
The trial had some delays Friday because Gurpreet Ronald said she was feeling ill. Her DNA was found at the crime scene, on knives and bloody gloves, court has heard. While Gill is expected to testify in his own defence it is still not known if Ronald will do the same.
The court has heard that Gill dumped one of the weapons days after the killing, and he was under police surveillance at the time.
Jagtar Gill was killed on her wedding anniversary.
The trial continues Monday.
She was the last to see her mother alive, and the first to find her dead.
The girl had stayed home from school that day â Jan. 29, 2014 â to look after her mom as she recovered from surgery. The girl didnât want to run errands with her father but he convinced her, and they went to the grocery store and bought roses and cake for her mom. It was their wedding anniversary.
When they returned from the grocery store, it was the girl, roses in her hand, who found her mom dead on the floor. Jagtar Gill was slashed and bludgeoned to death in the family room of her Barrhaven home.
The horrifying discovery was recounted by Gillâs daughter for police in a 2014 interview. A video of the interview was shown in court at her fatherâs first-degree murder trial. Bhupinderpal Gill and his mistress, Gurpreet Ronald, are on trial for killing his 43-year-old wife. The accused killers â both OC Transpo drivers â watched in silence as the girl recounted that awful afternoon.
She walked in the door (unlocked), kicked off her shoes and later âfrozeâ at the sight of her dead mom.
âThere was blood everywhere. I started yelling for my dad,â the girl told police in the 2014 interview.
She started crying, started breathing heavy, she said. She was too scared to check for a pulse, but it was clear from her severe wounds â including a slit throat â that she was dead.
âMy dadâs panicking,â she recalled. âHe was just yelling in a worried tone about nothing ⊠I kept hearing about suicide but she would never do that. She was happy,â the girl told police in the videotaped interview.
Her mother had in fact been killed, and worse, police said it was her father who conspired with his mistress to do it.
She said her father wondered aloud if it was a robbery.
The girl said she kept thinking: âWho would want to do this on my parentsâ anniversary?â
The detective told the girl the police were going to do their best to find out.
Earlier that day, her mother was joking around that theyâd be lost without her. If she died, she joked, nobody would know how to cut the pizza.
Her dad said theyâd figure it out, the daughter said.
The jury has heard about key DNA evidence against the mistress, Gurpreet Ronald. Her DNA was all over the murder weapons and the bloody gloves. The police say when Gill came home with his daughter on the day of the killing, he went to the kitchen and started washing the bloody knives used to kill his wife.
The jury has heard that Gill also dumped one of the murder weapons outside, and that Ronald dumped the bloody gloves in a park, according to police.
Gill is expected to testify in his own defence at the trial before Ontario Superior Court Justice Julianne Parfett. The trial continues Thursday.
If there is a normal way to act after your wife is found slashed and bludgeoned to death on the living room floor, this wasnât it.
It was Jan. 29, 2014, and just hours after Jagtar Gill was killed in her Barrhaven home. Scott Fewer, a family friend, paid a visit to Gillâs husband after hearing the news. The scene wasnât what Fewer expected, he testified Friday at Bhupinderpal Gillâs first-degree murder trial.
âI was struck by the lack of concern. There was nobody saying âI wonder who did this?â No one was crying,â Fewer told court about the conversation with Jagtar Gillâs husband and relatives hours after the killing.
Gill and his mistress, Gurpreet Ronald, are on trial for killing his 43-year-old wife. The accused killers â both OC Transpo drivers who booked the same shifts â sat in silence as they listened to Fewer recount what he branded as odd behaviour hours after the slaying.
He recalled asking Gill how he found his wife. Gill answered in a low-tone and said she had been slashed, the witness testified.Â
Then he recalled that Gill, a man of few words, motioned with his hand across his neck. (His wifeâs throat had been slit.)
âAnd nobodyâs asking âWho did this?'â Fewer recalled. There was no one running home and locking their doors, he said.
The neighbour, who became a family friend, was one of the last to see Jagtar Gill alive on the morning of her death, when he dropped by for coffee with her husband. Bhupinderpal Gill insisted he stay for breakfast, and started chopping up ingredients for an omelette.
Jagtar Gill was in the living room watching a Bollywood movie. She was laid up and recovering from surgery.Â
Jagtar Gill was killed on her anniversary.
âShe was doing good and recovering,â Fewer said.Â
He had met Bhupinderpal Gill about seven years ago when he helped him clear snow from his driveway so he could make his OC Transpo shift.Â
He said when heâd visit Gill at home, his mistress was usually around.Â
âTo me it always appeared like they were a couple. They were playful, joking,â Fewer recalled.
They were spending a lot of time together, and it made Fewer uncomfortable so he tried to âminimize my contact with him.â
Fewer, who teaches at Algonquin College, didnât want to be seen as âpromotingâ or âallowingâ the affair, he said.
He spent enough time with Gill and Ronald that they both shared details about their marriages, with Ronald saying hers had hit rock bottom.
âShe said their marriage was over and wanted to move on,â Fewer said.
Gurpreet Ronald
He recalled the day he went on a trip with Gill and Ronald to buy a motorcycle. Gill bought his mistress a pink helmet and she posed for the camera on the bike. She later posted them online, and Gill, upset, demanded she take them down.
âHe was not to happy about her posting those,â Fewer said.
Gill was also upset that his mistress was making plans to buy the house directly behind his family home.
âHe said: Iâm trying to convince her not to,â Fewer recalled.
Gill and Ronald have both pleaded not guilty. They are accused of killing Gillâs wife so they could finally be together.
Jagtar Gill was killed on the anniversary of her arranged marriage.
The jury has heard about key DNA evidence against the mistress, Gurpreet Ronald. Her DNA was all over the murder weapons and the bloody gloves. Police say when Gill came home with his daughter on the day of the killing, he went to the kitchen and started washing the bloody knives.
The jury has heard that Gill also dumped one of the weapons outside, and that Ronald dumped the bloody gloves in a park, according to police.
Gill is expected to testify in his own defence at the trial before Ontario Superior Court Justice Julianne Parfett. The trial continues Monday.